By choosing the right composite materials and working with a responsive contractor, Andrew Curtis saved $12,000 on his deck rebuild. The project highlights the value of smart material choices, clear communication, and understanding your options before starting a home improvement project.
How did smart material choices save $12,000 on a deck?
I had a wooden deck that was almost 20 years old, and the repair and maintenance costs were adding up—sometimes $2,000 to $5,000 every year. I wanted to rebuild it with composite materials to cut down on maintenance and long-term costs.
What made the vendor selection process important?
Finding the right contractor was a big step. I needed someone who would look at the project and not try to reinvent it. Fine Touch Services stood out because they respected the existing structure and worked with what we had, including the six by sixes and joists that were still in good shape.
How did material selection impact the budget?
Malcolm from Fine Touch Services helped us select a color-matching composite product that fit our budget. The initial estimates from other vendors were $12,000 higher. By choosing a quality composite with the same guarantee as the more expensive option, we saved a significant amount without sacrificing durability or appearance.
What was the experience during the deck rebuild?
Having Malcolm as the point person was critical. He was proactive, kept me updated, and answered every question—whether it was about the six by sixes, color matching, or the project timeline. The crew finished the deck about a month ago, and we finally got to use it for a backyard pitch-in with 20 people. The deck is the centerpiece for entertaining and family dinners.
How did design choices affect the final result?
We were able to color match the new composite to our existing table and even the posts. The railings allow us to see out from the house, which is elevated about five feet. The deck feels like a retreat—sometimes it feels like we’re in Tennessee, not Fishers. The attention to detail and the ability to see samples before making decisions made a big difference.
What advice can help with deck projects?
The best advice I can give is to educate yourself on materials before you start. Know what’s available, especially when it comes to railings—composite options can be limited. Malcolm helped us see samples and make informed choices. The design and material decisions really changed the look and feel of the deck, and I couldn’t be happier with the outcome.
“Smart material choices and a contractor who listens can save you thousands and deliver a deck you’ll love for years.”
— Andrew Curtis, Fishers, Indiana
Frequently Asked Questions
How did you save $12,000 on your deck project?
By choosing a quality composite material with the same guarantee as the more expensive option, we saved $12,000 without sacrificing durability or appearance.
What was the biggest challenge with composite materials?
The biggest challenge was finding railing options that matched our needs, since composite railings can be limited. Seeing samples helped us make the right choice.
How important is contractor communication?
Having a contractor who communicates and listens made the process smooth and ensured we got what we needed, not just what we asked for.
What advice do you have for someone planning a deck project?
Educate yourself on available materials and options before starting. This helps you make informed decisions and get the best value.
Jake Morris
About the Author
Jake Morris is the founder and owner of Fine Touch Services, a top-rated lawn care and landscaping company proudly serving Indianapolis and its northern suburbs since 2018. With a passion for outdoor living and a commitment to customer satisfaction, Jake leads a skilled team that delivers high-quality lawn, landscape, and hardscape services to over 8,000 clients annually. From designing serene garden retreats to building backyard entertainment spaces, Jake brings dedication, expertise, and a personal touch to every project. Learn more about Fine Touch Services. Or connect with Jake on LinkedIn.
